Murder Mystery 2 Mystery Boxes Explained: Which One to Buy
Mystery Box 2 is the better pick if you want a Godly. It is the first crate with four obtainable Godly weapons, two base Godlies and two Chroma Godlies, while Mystery Box 1 mostly holds older Season 1 weapons. Both cost the same: 1,000 Coins, 100 Diamonds or 1 Mystery Key.
Updated Sep 9, 2026. Source.
What boxes cost
Every Mystery Box in the shop costs the same three ways: 1,000 Coins earned from playing, 100 Diamonds (the premium currency bought with Robux), or 1 Mystery Key. Coins are free, so a new player can save up and open a box without spending anything.
Box 1 versus Box 2
Mystery Box 1 still runs mostly Season 1 weapons and has fewer Godly options. Mystery Box 2 added four obtainable Godlies, two base and two Chroma, which makes it the stronger pick if a Godly is what you are after.
Play the odds, not the hype
Nikilis has not published exact drop percentages, but Godly and Chroma pulls from either box sit under 1 percent. No box guarantees a Godly. Only spend Coins you are fine losing to bad luck, and if you want one specific knife rather than a random Godly, trading for it directly is usually faster and more predictable than opening boxes.
FAQ
What is the difference between Mystery Box 1 and Mystery Box 2 in MM2?
Box 2 has four obtainable Godly weapons, two base and two Chroma, while Box 1 mostly holds older Season 1 items with fewer Godly options. Both cost 1,000 Coins, 100 Diamonds or 1 Mystery Key.
Players ask this on Reddit.
More Murder Mystery 2 guides
Fan-made tools. The Gamers Hub is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Murder Mystery 2 or its developers. Values are community estimates, not official prices. Roblox is a trademark of Roblox Corporation.